Skip to content

Reverse second mortgage vs HELOC vs cash-out refinance

The short answer

A cash-out refinance replaces your whole first mortgage, usually at today's rate. A HELOC keeps your first mortgage but adds a monthly payment. A reverse second mortgage keeps your first mortgage and does not add a required monthly payment, but its balance grows over time.

*No monthly payment is required on this loan. You must still pay your first mortgage, property taxes, insurance, HOA dues and upkeep, and live in the home. Interest is added to the balance, which grows over time. Important disclosures

Cash-out refinance

You get one new, larger first mortgage. If your current rate is lower than today's rates, your payment on the money you already owed can rise.

Qualifying is based on income and credit, and the monthly payment starts right away.

HELOC

A HELOC is a second loan you draw from as needed. Your first mortgage stays, but you make monthly payments on what you borrow, and the rate usually changes over time.

Qualifying typically depends on income, which can be harder in retirement.

Reverse second mortgage

Your first mortgage stays in place. Interest on the new loan is added to its balance instead of being billed monthly, so the amount you owe grows and the equity you keep shrinks.

You still pay property taxes, homeowners insurance and upkeep, and you keep paying your first mortgage. Interest is added to the balance over time, so the equity left for you or your heirs goes down. The loan comes due when you sell, move out or no longer live in the home, and not meeting the loan terms can lead to foreclosure.

How to choose

If keeping monthly costs low matters most and you plan to stay in the home, a reverse second mortgage may be worth comparing. If you want to keep as much equity as possible and can afford payments, a HELOC or refinance may cost less overall. Compare total costs, not just payments.

Common questions

Which option costs the least?
It depends on how long you keep the loan and how much you pay along the way. Loans with a monthly payment often cost less in total interest; loans without one keep monthly cash flow lower.
Can I compare my own numbers?
Yes. The free fit check on this site shows estimates side by side, with no credit pull.

See your own numbers

About 60 seconds. No credit pull.

Check my fit

Related guides